Flooring Buying Guide
Last updated: July 17, 2019 https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/flooring/buying-guide/index.htm
Installing a new floor is one of the more expensive home improvement projects you’ll undertake. With so many choices—hardwood, laminate, engineered wood, vinyl, tile—where do you begin?
Budget is certain to factor into your decision. But you should also consider how much foot traffic, sunlight, and wear and tear your flooring will endure.
For example, some engineered woods, along with a few solid wood types of flooring, aren’t as resistant to moisture as vinyl or laminate flooring—a serious drawback in a bathroom or busy kitchen. Porcelain tile would be a better choice for durability, but it can be expensive and requires labor-intensive installation.
To help you choose, we put the most common flooring types and brands, including Armstrong, Lumber Liquidators, Pergo, and Tarkett, through a series of tough tests. Use the ratings to select the type that’s best for the room or rooms you’re renovating.
Find the Best Flooring for Your Home
We test, evaluate, and compare the latest flooring to help you beautify your home.
Become a Member
How We Test Flooring
We test wear resistance by subjecting a 6×6-inch sample of each flooring material to an abrasion machine fitted with a fine sandpaper disc, and assessing each sample for signs of visible wear after each cycle of sanding.
To test a floor’s resistance to denting, we drop a heavy, blunt weight that simulates a saucepan or a large can of tomatoes, plus a smaller, lighter, pointier object that serves as a proxy for kitchen utensils. Our testers drop the weights from progressively higher release points, examining the flooring for visible denting after each drop. The higher the drop before damage becomes evident, the better a floor’s dent-resistance rating.
We evaluate potential for fading by exposing part of a sample of flooring to UV rays for two weeks straight, then comparing the exposed portion to an unexposed portion. This gives us information on what can happen to a section of flooring that gets more sunlight than the rest of a room over time.
Types of Flooring
Most flooring falls into one of the following six types. The type you choose will depend on your needs and budget—not to mention your personal style and aesthetic.
Solid wood flooring.
Solid Wood Flooring
Pros: Wood has a natural warmth and impressive wear resistance, and it can be sanded and refinished several times. Prefinished floors can hold up better than those finished on-site, and their warranty comes from the factory, not the installer, giving you the reputability of a big company standing behind its product. With a private installer, you might have a tougher time getting a refund if your floors are installed improperly.
Cons: Solid wood will expand and contract with varying humidity levels and can dent easily. Some species can show wear quickly and become discolored from sunlight. Note: Unfinished flooring costs less than prefinished, but higher installation costs can offset savings. Wood flooring is not a good choice for basements and other damp spaces.
Installed cost: $5 to $10 per square foot.
See Our Flooring Ratings For More On Solid Wood
Flooring that is engineered wood.
Engineered Wood Flooring
Pros: Because engineered wood is typically made of thin layers of wood sandwiched with adhesives, it can usually withstand higher levels of humidity and would be less likely to expand when compared with solid wood flooring. This flooring uses a thin veneer of real wood or bamboo over structural plywood, making it a cost-effective choice. Well-installed, high-quality engineered wood can be as durable as solid wood.
Cons: Most engineered wood doesn’t wear as well as solid wood or laminate. It also dents easily, despite differences in wood species. Depending on the thickness of the veneer, some engineered wood flooring can be refinished as many times as solid hardwood flooring. However, most can be refinished only once or twice, and some can never be refinished. If you think you may need to refinish your engineered wood flooring, check with the manufacturer or retailer before you buy.
Installed cost: $4 to $9 per square foot.
For More On Engineered Wood Check Our Flooring Ratings
Pros: Constructed of dense fiberboard with a photo beneath a clear-plastic protective layer, laminate can mimic almost anything.
Some brands use a cork backing underneath, which they claim can help muffle sound. The best laminates resist scratching and discoloration from sunlight better than most wood products. It can be extremely tough stuff.
Cons: The repetitive pattern can compromise realism (read: look fake), so when installing, mix planks from different boxes for a less repetitive pattern. In terms of durability, you might be able to touch up minor flaws, but you’ll have to replace the flooring once its top layer has worn through, because it can’t be sanded like wood.
Installed cost: $3 to $7 per square foot.
Read Our Flooring Ratings To Find The Best Laminate
Pros: Especially good at fending off wear, dents, scratches, discoloration from sunlight, and stains. Easy installation, particularly for tiles or planks, and more color and design choices are available these days.
Cons: While the premium brands can mimic the look of stone, tile, and even oak, even the best products still look like vinyl up close. Top-of-the-line vinyl can cost as much as or more than the best solid wood and laminate floors.
Installed cost: $2 to $6 per square foot.
See Our Flooring Ratings For More On Vinyl
Pros: Made of linseed oil and wood products, linoleum is a natural, resilient material. Today’s products offer far more styles and colors. Linoleum tends to fend off discoloration from sunlight.
Cons: Resistance to wear, scratches, and dents varies widely from product to product.
Installed cost: $4 to $8 per square foot.
For The Top Linoleum Options Check Our Flooring Ratings
Porcelain tile flooring.
Porcelain Tile Flooring
Pros: This classic material tends to resist wear, moisture, scratches, dents, and stains.
Cons: Installing porcelain tiles can be challenging. A lot of prep work is needed, and your subfloor needs to be perfectly smooth before you can set your tile in thinset and put grout in the cracks. For most applications, it might be best to hire a professional. Tiles can crack, and some grout can stain. Dropped cups and dishes break more easily. Tile is also relatively expensive and more difficult to install. Replacing cracked tiles can be a challenge.
Installed cost: $8 to $15 per square foot; $5 to $8 for products that can float.
Sampling Is Smart
Before you buy, get samples of your top flooring choices. Compare them side-by-side where they’re going to be installed, and look at them from different angles and in different light.
Compare for Consistency
Manufacturers try to match solid and engineered wood flooring for color and grain. But variations can occur from one batch to the next, so buy all the flooring you’ll need at one time. On the flip side, laminate floorboards within a given package may have an identical pattern that the eye can pick up if installed too close together. To reduce repetition, shuffle boards from multiple packages when installing.
Measuring Avoids Mistakes
To determine how much flooring you’ll need, measure the room’s square footage by multiplying its length times its width. (Divide an irregularly shaped room into smaller rectangles, calculate the square footage of each rectangle, and then add them together.) Then buy 7 to 10 percent extra to allow for mistakes, bad samples, and waste. Consider buying an extra box of flooring, in addition to the 7 to 10 percent extra, for future repairs or additions.
Know Your Traffic Patterns
Common high-traffic areas are entryways to rooms and to the house itself. Consider very resilient flooring for family rooms and other lounge areas that pets and kids frequent. Our top products performed best in simulated foot-traffic tests. For less busy areas, consider one of the top engineered wood or bamboo floors, for their natural veneer and easy installation.
Preparing to Install Flooring
Before installing wood or laminate flooring, unpack it and let it sit for one to three days in the space where it will be installed so that its temperature and moisture content will find equilibrium with the levels in the room. This is a critical step to prevent buckling or unsightly gaps between boards.
Check for Certification
Vinyl floors with the industry’s FloorScore certification (pictured below) emit relatively low levels of volatile organic compounds—substances linked to health problems and pollution. For wood flooring, certification by the Forest Stewardship Council and the Sustainable Forestry Initiative offers some assurance that your flooring comes from responsibly managed forests—a plus for the planet. Check packaging for product and manufacturer certification.